The World Florine Stettheimer Chose to Paint

Stettheimer ignored the still lifes and landscapes her peers traded in. Her subjects were her sisters, her salon, the city outside her window and the theatre she helped reinvent.

Auvrique Editorial · Fine Art Editions

The short answer

Florine Stettheimer explored four main subjects: portraits of her family and circle of artist friends, satirical scenes of New York high society, a series of large paintings of the city itself titled the Cathedrals, and stage and costume design, most notably for Gertrude Stein's opera Four Saints in Three Acts in 1934. She also painted flower still lifes.

Portraits of a World She Knew

Stettheimer painted the people in her own rooms. Her sisters Ettie and Carrie appear again and again, along with the writers, dancers and collectors who passed through the salon she kept in Manhattan. The recurring motifs in Florine Stettheimer's work are social rather than natural. She was interested in how people arrange themselves, how they pose, and what their furniture says about them.

These are not flattering portraits in the conventional sense. Figures are elongated, slightly cartoonish, and set against flat fields of white or pale color. The effect is affectionate satire. She records a dinner party or an afternoon at the beach the way a witty guest would describe it afterward, with everyone's self-importance intact and gently punctured. The best prints for a modern living room often come from exactly this body of work, where the composition does the decorating.

New York as Her Cathedral

In the last decade of her life Stettheimer turned to the city itself. The Cathedrals series, painted in the 1930s and early 1940s, treats Wall Street, Broadway, Fifth Avenue and the art world as the true sacred sites of American life. Skyscrapers rise like Gothic spires. Flags, billboards and crowds fill the frames. It was an unfashionable subject at the time, when most American painters looked to rural scenes.

What makes the series hold up is the double view. The paintings celebrate the energy of Manhattan and mock it at once. Advertising and commerce sit alongside genuine grandeur, and Stettheimer refuses to rank them. Readers weighing which subjects suit their own walls can compare the city paintings with calmer options such as the Outskirts of Lausanne canvas, which shows how differently a landscape carries a room.

The Cathedrals also belong to a specific moment. They were painted through the Depression, when the confidence of the skyline was not a neutral fact. Her treatment of banks, theaters and museums keeps that tension visible rather than smoothing it over.

Theatre, Ballet and Design

Stettheimer's most public subject was the stage. In 1934 she designed the sets and costumes for Four Saints in Three Acts, Gertrude Stein's opera with music by Virgil Thomson, staged with an all-Black cast in Hartford and on Broadway. The production used cellophane, a material then new to theatre design, and it made her a public figure for a brief period after decades of private work.

The theatrical instinct runs through everything else she painted. Her canvases are staged rather than observed. Figures face the viewer as if on a proscenium, gestures are exaggerated, and color is applied for effect rather than accuracy. This is why her work translates so well to reproduction, and why the palette questions covered in the guide to her most-used colors matter when choosing an edition. A painting conceived as spectacle survives printing better than one built on subtle tonal shifts.

She also painted flower still lifes throughout her career, looser and warmer than the social scenes. These are the least conceptual of her subjects and the most purely decorative, which is not a criticism. She knew the difference.

She painted her own living room and called it America.

Subject	Where it appears	What it carries
Family and salon portraits	Paintings from the 1910s through the 1930s	Satire of her own social class
New York City	The Cathedrals series, 1930s and early 1940s	Commerce treated as religion
Stage and costume design	Four Saints in Three Acts, 1934	Theatre logic applied to painting
Flower still lifes	Throughout her career	Color and decoration without irony

Stettheimer's recurring subjects at a glance

Key takeaways

Her core subjects were her family, her salon circle, New York City and the theatre.
The Cathedrals series treats Wall Street and Broadway as the sacred monuments of modern America.
She designed sets and costumes for Gertrude Stein's Four Saints in Three Acts in 1934.
Her staged, high-color style translates unusually well to reproduction prints.

Related questions

Did Florine Stettheimer sell her paintings during her lifetime?

Almost never. She showed her work in exhibitions, including the 1916 Independents show, but she largely declined to sell, preferring to keep the paintings together. Most entered public collections after her death in 1944, notably through a memorial exhibition. This is one reason her market operates differently from artists with long auction records.

What is the Cathedrals series about?

It is a group of large paintings from the 1930s and early 1940s depicting New York institutions as modern cathedrals, covering Wall Street, Broadway, Fifth Avenue and the art world. The series treats skyscrapers, advertising and crowds with equal parts admiration and mockery, which is the signature tension of her late work.

Was Stettheimer part of a movement?

She is usually grouped with American modernists of the interwar years, though she fits no school neatly. Her flat color and satirical figures sit closer to folk and theatrical traditions than to Cubism or Precisionism. She exhibited alongside European modernists in New York but developed her style largely in private.

From the Auvrique collection

Made to order · Every size