How to judge the quality of a Jeffrey Smart print

A Jeffrey Smart print is only as good as the reproduction method and the paper it sits on. The obvious tests are simple, and the expensive ones are not.

Auvrique Editorial · Fine Art Editions

The short answer

Look first at the print method. A high quality Jeffrey Smart print is usually a giclée or a fine art inkjet on acid free paper, not a cheap offset poster. Check the colour against a known Smart painting. The shadows in his urban scenes should hold detail, not go flat. Hold the print at an angle to the light. You should see no visible dot pattern and no banding in the smooth areas.

What the print method tells you

The first question is not about the image but about the machine that made it. A poster printed in bulk on coated magazine stock will look flat next to a giclée run on cotton rag. Smart's paintings depend on hard light and long shadows, and that range is the first thing a poor process flattens. Ask the seller which process they use and on what paper. A short answer is usually a better answer than a long one.

Do not trust the word archival on its own. It has been stretched to cover cheap processes. A genuinely well made print will name the ink set and the paper weight, or at least describe the paper by its feel and composition. If the listing only says considered paper, treat that as a warning rather than a promise. The buyer who asks for the process usually gets a more honest reply.

What to look for on the surface

Put the print under a light and move it slowly. A good reproduction stays even. A poor one shows a pattern of dots, a mottled sky, or bands where the colour should change smoothly. Smart's painted surfaces often include long stretches of concrete, road and sky, and those are exactly the areas where a weak print gives itself away. The eye is quicker than the marketing copy.

Check the edges and the corners. A well finished print is cut cleanly and squared to the image. Crooked trimming and white slivers at the margins suggest a press that was not set up carefully. The frame can hide a lot, but it cannot hide a print that was made carelessly. A buyer who inspects the edges before paying is usually the buyer who does not return the work.

Quality indicators for prints

No visible halftone dot pattern under a strong light
Smooth colour transitions in sky and concrete areas
Clean square cuts with no white slivers at the edges
Paper that feels substantial rather than glossy and thin

How the colour should read

Smart's palette is built around hard sunlight, pale walls and deep shadow. A reproduction that is too warm will turn his roads orange and his shadows muddy. A reproduction that is too cool will make the same scene feel dead. Compare the print to a Smart painting you have seen in a book or on a screen you trust, and look at the midtones first. The extremes are easy to fake. The middle is where the quality shows.

The real risk for a skeptical buyer is paying a mid range price for a print that looks acceptable on a screen and poor on the wall. A print can look fine at full brightness on a phone and still lose the contrast that makes a Smart image work. If you can, view a sample in the room where it will hang. Light changes the painting more than most buyers expect.

A Smart painting lives on hard light and long shadow. A cheap print flattens both and leaves the image looking like a postcard of itself.

Key takeaways

Ask which print process and which paper were used before you pay.
Inspect the surface under a strong light for dots and banding.
Check the midtones against a Smart painting you already know.
View a sample in the room where it will hang, not only on a screen.

Related questions

Is a canvas print better than a paper print for a Jeffrey Smart image?

Not always. Canvas can suit a large Smart scene with broad areas of colour, but it can also soften the sharp edges that give his work its character. Paper on a good frame often reads more clearly for the urban subjects he painted most often. The better test is the quality of the print itself, not the support it is printed on.

What price should I expect for a well made Jeffrey Smart print?

A fair price depends on the process, the paper and the size, and it is hard to give a single number without knowing those things. A cheap offset poster and a fine art giclée are different products with different costs. If the price seems low for the size and the process described, ask what has been cut to reach it.

Can I tell the quality of a Jeffrey Smart print from a photograph online?

Only partly. A good photograph can hide banding and colour drift, and a bad one can make a decent print look worse than it is. Use the listing image to check the composition, then ask for more detail on the process and the paper. If the seller will not say more, that is itself a useful piece of information.

From the Auvrique collection

Made to order · Every size